Originally published on September 15, 2020 and updated on November 14, 2024

When buying, selling, or trading cryptocurrency, you’ll encounter two popular options: peer-to-peer (P2P) marketplaces and centralized exchanges. Both get the job done but take different approaches, each with advantages and disadvantages. So, which one is right for you?

Let’s break it down.

P2P marketplaces like Paxful let buyers and sellers trade cryptocurrencies directly, pairing two individual traders. Think of it as eBay for crypto—where users can set their prices and agree on terms before completing a trade. 

On the other hand, centralized exchanges (CEXs) like Binance or Coinbase operate like traditional financial exchanges, offering a more centralized order book for trading cryptocurrencies – more like an Amazon than an eBay, to continue the analogy.

So, what’s more important to you? 

Do you want more control over your trades? Or would you prefer something more straightforward, even if it means trusting a third party with your funds?

Read on to learn more.

---

What is a P2P crypto marketplace?

In a  P2P (peer-to-peer) crypto marketplace, individuals connect directly to trade cryptocurrencies without intermediaries. Buyers and sellers can agree on terms, set prices, and finalize transactions independently, providing more freedom and flexibility. 

What are the benefits of P2P crypto platforms?

P2P platforms offer several key advantages:

• Lower fees: With no intermediaries, costs are often reduced.
• Flexibility: More payment options are available compared to centralized exchanges.
• Global access: You can trade across borders easily.
• More payment options. Typically, P2P crypto marketplaces have more payment options to meet users varied needs. For example, Paxful has over 300 payment options. 
• Direct control over funds: Users don’t need to trust a third party with their money, further reducing the risks of losses due to hacking or company bankruptcy.

How do transactions work in P2P crypto marketplaces?

P2P crypto transactions follow a simple process as follows:

1. A seller posts an offer to sell crypto, usually at above-market rates.
2. A buyer selects an offer they like from the various offers.
3. Both parties agree on the trade terms and initiate a peer-to-peer payment.
4. Once payment is confirmed, the platform releases the crypto to the buyer, usually from an escrow account. This ensures security and transparency for both parties.
5. To keep things transparent and fair, many P2P platforms, such as Paxful, use a reputation system where users rate each other after trades, helping build trust in the community.

---

This might interest you: How to Use Paxful.

---

What is a crypto exchange?

A crypto exchange acts as an intermediary, facilitating the trading of cryptocurrencies between buyers and sellers. Crypto exchanges offer different features such as:

• Order matching
• Wallet services 
• Fiat-on ramps
• Security measures to make trading safe.
• Education resources on cryptocurrencies 

Additionally, crypto exchanges often prove transactions through blockchain technology. Each transaction is recorded on a public ledger, creating a transparent and trackable record. This feature can be helpful for compliance purposes, as it leaves trails of the origin and movement of funds between parties.

How does a crypto exchange work?

Crypto exchanges use an order book system to match buy and sell orders and determine fair market prices. When someone wants to buy an asset such as Bitcoin (BTC), the exchange finds a seller willing to trade at that price. This system shows all open buy and sell orders and helps set fair market prices for cryptocurrencies.

Exchanges earn money through fees charged on a small percentage of each trade; some have deposit or withdrawal fees similar to how a sales tax would apply. 

Security is a top concern for Exchanges, and they apply enhanced security features such as cold storage to keep your funds safe. 

Nine differences between crypto exchange and P2P crypto marketplaces

1. Trading mechanism

• P2P crypto marketplaces: Users trade directly with each other, often without a central authority holding their assets. The platform acts as a facilitator by providing a place for buyers and sellers to connect, offering escrow services to ensure safe transactions. 
• Crypto exchanges: Here, users trade with the exchange itself or against the order book, where buy and sell orders are matched automatically by the platform’s matching engine. 

2. Decentralization vs. centralization

• P2P crypto marketplaces offer more decentralized trading because users maintain custody of their assets until a trade is agreed upon and finalized. This gives users greater control and the ability to choose payment methods that suit them (e.g., bank transfer, PayPal, gift cards).
• Crypto exchanges take custody of users’ assets, which can increase risks related to hacking or platform failures. Still, they streamline trading and offer liquidity for various pairs, making them more convenient for fast trades.

3. Payment methods

• P2P crypto marketplaces: Offer a wide variety of payment options. Users can exchange crypto using hundreds of methods, including digital wallets, gift cards, and fiat transfers. This flexibility attracts users in countries where traditional banking services are inaccessible.
• Crypto exchanges: Typically offer fewer payment methods, mostly fiat on-ramps like bank transfers, credit/debit cards, and crypto deposits. These exchanges prioritize speed and liquidity over flexibility.

4. Liquidity and pricing

• P2P crypto marketplaces: Liquidity is provided by individual users, so prices can vary based on the seller’s offer and regional availability. This may lead to less consistent pricing but sometimes offers arbitrage opportunities.
• Crypto exchanges have more liquidity and more competitive, real-time pricing due to large volumes and matching orders across a broad user base. This leads to tighter spreads and more predictable pricing.

5. Transaction speed

• P2P Cryptomarketplaces: Transactions can take longer because they depend on when buyers and sellers agree, complete payment, and finalize the trade (including escrow release). Delays can occur due to verification of payment method.
• Crypto exchanges: Transactions happen instantly once buy/sell orders are matched, making these platforms more suitable for those seeking speed, especially traders.

6. User autonomy vs. platform control

• P2P crypto marketplaces: Users can set prices, choose payment methods, and negotiate deals more freely. The platform only steps in if disputes arise.
• Crypto exchanges: The platform controls much of the user experience, from trading pairs offered to order matching. Users have less freedom regarding pricing and payment options but benefit from structured, predictable trading environments.

7. Audience and use case

• P2P crypto marketplaces: Typically cater to users in emerging markets or those looking for alternative ways to access or spend crypto without relying on traditional banking infrastructure. The flexibility of payment options attracts users needing local solutions.
• Crypto exchanges: Primarily serve traders, investors, and users looking for a seamless way to buy, sell, or trade various crypto assets with high liquidity. Institutional investors and retail traders use these platforms for faster transaction times and reliability.

8. Security and risk

• P2P crypto marketplaces: Offer escrow services to reduce risks, but there’s always the potential for disputes or fraudulent activity. Trust is vital in P2P transactions, which can sometimes result in a higher risk of scams if proper due diligence isn’t followed.
• Crypto exchanges: These platforms are often more secure regarding technical infrastructure, but they are attractive targets for hackers since they hold large amounts of user assets. Platform breaches, although rare, can result in significant losses.

9. Ease of use

• P2P crypto marketplaces have a steeper learning curve, as users must understand how to navigate listings and communicate with other traders. This can be challenging for newcomers to cryptocurrency trading. P2P markets have mobile apps, but their user interfaces may not always be polished to the same level.
• Centralized exchanges offer simple buy-and-sell options, making them accessible to beginners. These platforms often include advanced trading features for experienced users. Centralized exchanges usually provide mobile apps and desktop platforms.

Bottom line: Which one is right for you?

Choosing between a P2P marketplace and a centralized exchange comes down to your priorities. If you value control over your assets and want flexibility in payment methods, a P2P-like Paxful marketplace might be for you. However, a centralized exchange comes with specific advantages, as outlined above. 

The bottom line is that both options have their place in the crypto ecosystem. It’s about finding the right balance of security, autonomy, and convenience for your trading needs.